FLORIDA LITIGATION | SETTLEMENT STRATEGY | PROPOSAL FOR SETTLEMENT | FEE-SHIFTING STATUTES
How formal offers of judgment under Rule 1.442 and Fla. Stat. § 768.79 create fee-shifting risk and accelerate pretrial resolution.
Published: January 15, 2024
Primary Case Law: Kuhajda v. Borden Dairy Co. of Alabama; State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Nichols
Applicable Rules & Statutes: Fla. Stat. § 768.79; Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.442; Fla. Stat. § 57.104
Jurisdiction: Florida State Courts
What Is a Proposal for Settlement under Florida Law?
A proposal for a settlement under Florida law is a formal offer made in civil litigation under Florida Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 1.442 and Florida Revised Statutes § 768.79. A party declining an offer may face penalties and costs if the results achieved at trial are significantly less than what was offered in a proposal for settlement.
Our injury lawyers in Coral Gables, FL at Maderal Byrne & Furst PLLC explain what you need to know about evaluating a proposal for settlement.
Understanding Proposals for Settlement in Florida
Civil litigation is a legal dispute between two parties. Before a case goes to trial, either party may make an offer of settlement. A settlement offer proposes terms and conditions to resolve the case without the need for trial.
Florida civil litigation features a process where a settlement offer may be made formally, and potentially with serious consequences for a party declining an offer. This process is called a proposal for a settlement.
What is a proposal for a settlement in Florida?
Florida law allows a party in a pending lawsuit to propose a settlement. When the proposal follows the requirements of Florida Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 1.442 and Florida Revised Statutes § 768.79, the other party has 30 days to accept the proposal. If they don’t, and the outcome at trial is 25% or lower for the declining party, the party is liable to pay costs and attorney fees for the offering party, from the date of the settlement proposal.
Proposal for Settlement Statute
There are two primary authorities for proposal for a settlement in Florida law.
Florida Revised Statutes § 768.79
Florida Revised Statutes § 768.79 authorizes offers of settlement and creates rules for how they work. To be official, an offer of settlement must:
- Be in writing
- Invoke § 768.79 as its authority
- Name the parties involved in the offer
- State the total amount
- Specify any amount offered for punitive damages
An offer includes all damages that may be awarded in the case. Furthermore, it must be served directly on the party to whom it is made.
Florida Rules of Civil Procedure – Rule 1.442
Florida Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 1.442 further governs how offers of settlement work in Florida. It says:
- The plaintiff may serve an offer no sooner than 90 days after the defendant has been served with case documents.
- The defense may serve an offer no sooner than 90 days after an action has commenced.
- Either party may extend an offer up to 45 days before trial.
Other statutes may be relevant in specific types of cases. See Florida Revised Statutes § 624.1552 and Florida Statutes § 70.001(4)(c).
The 25% rule and proposals for settlement
A proposal for settlement is a formal offer to resolve a case. It carries potential consequences for a litigant who chooses to reject it.
If a plaintiff’s award is 25% less than the defendant’s proposed settlement offer, or if the plaintiff loses the case entirely, the court awards costs and attorney fees to the defendant from the date of the offer. The net result may be a financial judgment for the defendant even if the plaintiff is awarded compensation at trial.
Similarly, if the plaintiff extends a settlement demand, and the result achieved at trial is a judgment 25% or higher than the offer, the court awards attorney fees and costs to the plaintiff. Consequently, fees and costs are awarded from the date the offer was served.
Recent amendments and non-monetary terms in settlement proposals
Under Florida Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 1.442, proposals for settlement cannot include non-monetary terms. For example, confidentiality agreements, provisions to hold harmless, requirements for cooperation, or releases of all claims are prohibited within formal proposals. An exception exists for the voluntary dismissal of all claims with prejudice, alongside other statutory exceptions allowed by law.
Proponents of this rule structure state that it aligns Rule 1.442 more consistently with Florida Statutes § 768.79. Conversely, critics argue that excluding non-monetary terms may cause a higher number of claims to proceed to trial, as non-monetary terms often represent a critical component of reaching a mutually agreeable resolution.
Proposal for settlement example
Consider a scenario where the plaintiff sues the defendant in a personal injury case. The plaintiff extends a formal settlement offer to the defendant, offering to settle the case for $70,000. However, the defendant declines. The case proceeds to trial, where the court awards the plaintiff $100,000—approximately 40% more than the amount offered in settlement.
The case result triggers the offer of settlement penalties. The plaintiff can claim their litigation costs and attorney fees from the date they extended the offer. Having to pay fees and costs — or have them deducted — can significantly change an award of compensation.
Florida Proposal for Settlement FAQs
What is the purpose of a proposal for settlement in Florida?
The purpose of a proposal for settlement in Florida is to encourage the resolution of disputes, conserve judicial resources and encourage parties to seriously pursue non-trial resolution.
If I propose a settlement under Florida law, is it admissible at trial?
No. A proposal for settlement made under Florida law is not admissible at trial. It is filed in court if it is accepted or needs to be enforced.
How do you accept a proposal for settlement in Florida?
To accept a proposal for settlement for settlement in Florida, file an acceptance with the court within 30 days of the offer. When both the offer and acceptance are filed, the court has jurisdiction to enforce the offer.
Who decides if attorney’s fees are reasonable for a Florida proposal of settlement?
The court may determine the reasonableness of attorney’s fees sought under a Florida proposal of settlement offer. They may consider numerous factors relating to the litigation.
Can you withdraw a proposal for settlement in Florida?
You can withdraw a proposal for settlement in Florida before it is accepted.
Talk to a Lawyer
Have you received a proposal for settlement? Are you wondering how to extend a proposal for settlement? Do you have other questions about your case?
About Maderal Byrne & Furst
Maderal Byrne & Furst PLLC is a Miami-based personal injury law firm. We encourage you to learn more about our firm, meet our attorneys, explore our other practice areas, view our results or see our rating and reviews on Google.
Contact Maderal Byrne & Furst PLLC today for a free consultation.
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This blog post is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law is subject to change, and the application of legal principles varies depending on the specific facts of each case. If you have questions about your specific situation, you should consult a licensed Florida attorney.
Citations & Sources
-
Fla. Stat. § 768.79 (Offer of Judgment and Demand for Judgment)
-
Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.442 (Proposals for Settlement)
-
Fla. Stat. § 57.104 (Determination of Reasonable Attorney’s Fees)